Add your deal, information or promotional text

Fake Bakes Recipe - Sainsburys Cookies and Cream Cake

We all scream for Cookies and Cream...am I right, or am I right? When I put a poll out on Instagram on which £10 Fake Bake cakes our followers would like me to attempt, one of THE MOST requested flavours was cookies and cream. Which isn't a particular surprise to me considering one of our most popular birthday cakes is our Doughnut Cookie Monster cake.

Doughnut Cookie Monster Cake

Personally, Oreos don't do much for me. But crush 'em up and whizz them in a milkshake, or ice cream, or any dessert and I'm all over it! Oreo cookies are omnipresent, but Oreo-based treats are also very easily found. For this week's challenge I went to Sainsbury's (where I last had brilliant luck with my Chocolate Orange Fake Bake) and saw ALL THE OREO THINGS!

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - cookies and cream treats

 After X-Ray and I loaded up the trolley with all things cookies and cream, including the Hershey's Cookies and Cream bars. sadly we went way over budget. I must've spent an agonising 30 minutes deliberating over what to put back on the shelves. It was a very tough elimination, and I had to cull the Hershey's bars.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - ingredients

I decided upon two chocolate layer cakes, a tub of Sainsbury's own vanilla frosting, two bars of Lovett's white chocolate (30p each!), a double pack of Oreo cookies, a bag of Cadbury's chocolate covered Oreo bites, and cookies and cream straws. It all came under the £10 Fake Bake budget at a grand total of £9.70.

And dare I say it...it may have beaten my personal favourite...the Aldi Mint Choc Chip cake in the looks department.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe

 

Fake Bake Recipe - Cookies and Cream Cake

Ingredients

2x Ready-made Round Chocolate Layer Cakes (5" or 6" size)

1 tub (400g) of ready-made Vanilla flavour frosting

2 packs of Oreo cookies

2 bars of white chocolate

Cadburys Oreo Bites

Cookies and Cream Straws  

Method

1. Prepare the cake decorating station with a cake turntable, angled palette knife, cake scraper, a cake board, a tablespoon, a piping bag fitted with a small star nozzle, a knife and a spatula.  

2. Unbox the cakes. Smear a dollop of frosting in the middle of the cake board on the turntable, and then place one of the layer cakes on the board. Remove any paper wrapping along the edges.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - first layer cake 

3. Crush 7-8 Oreo cookies into fine powder, almost sand-like texture.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - crush oreos
Decant the frosting into a bowl and stir or whip a tablespoon of the Oreo powder into it. 
Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - oreo frosting

4. Smooth the top of the layer cake. Stack the second layer cake on top and remove any paper wrapping.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - stack layer cakes

Pipe the frosting around the cake.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - pipe frosting

Run a cake scraper along the sides of the cake to smooth. Smooth the top of the cake.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - smooth frosting

5. Roughly chop 10 Oreos with a knife. Crust the base of the frosted cake with the chopped Oreo crumble until halfway up. 

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - crust cake with oreo crumbs

6. Make the cookies and cream white chocolate bars. Have a dry tea towel to hand. Pour boiling water into a mug. Dip a teaspoon or melon baller into the hot water and let it warm up for a few seconds. Pull the spoon out and dry it thoroughly on the tea towel. Using the back of the spoon/melon baller, melt the surface of a segment on the white chocolate bar. Press chopped Oreo pieces onto the melted surface.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - cookies and cream chocolate bar method
Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - cookies and cream white chocolate bar

7. Make the white chocolate water ganache drip. Melt half a white chocolate bar over a double boiler or in a microwave safe bowl at 30 seconds at a time, stirring between each blast. Heat 3 tablespoons of water until just simmering and pour gently into the melted chocolate and stir to combine until smooth.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - white chocolate water ganache

Stir a teaspoon of Oreo powder into the white ganache.

8. Prepare the chocolate dipped Oreos. Melt half a bar of white chocolate over a bain marie or in the microwave in short 30 second bursts. Dip Oreo cookies halfway into the melted white chocolate and place on a plate/tray lined with parchment paper to set in the fridge. 

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - white chocolate dipped oreo

Fill the muffin cores with the mint choc ganache and chill them in the fridge to set.

Fake Bake Mint Choc Chip Cake Recipe - fill muffin cores

9. Pour a tablespoon of Oreo white ganache along the sides of the cake. Use the back of the spoon to push drips gently over the edge.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - oreo ganache drip

10. Fit a piping bag with a small star nozzle tip and fill with the remaining frosting. Pipe swirls over the top of the cake.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - pipe frosting swirls
Chop the Cadbury's bites and Oreo white chocolate bar.
Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - chop oreo bites and cookies and cream chocolate bar

Decorate the cake using the Cadbury Oreo bites, Oreo white chocolate shards, chocolate dipped Oreos and cookies and cream straws.

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - decorate

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - feature image

I think you'll agree this is a mighty fine looking cake for under a tenner. I managed to get some real mileage out of the cheap white chocolate by using it to make the Oreo ganache drip, white chocolate dipped Oreos and also the Oreo chocolate shards. Totally worth the Hershey's sacrifice!

Fake Bakes Cookies and Cream Cake Recipe - slice

I might as well retire from this series now that I've peak-peaked. Hah, just kidding! I've still STILL got to try out Asda ;)

If this seems like a lot of work or if you want a sure-bet cake for a special occasion you can always order one of our luxury cakes delivered across London. Until next time!

Lots of love,

Reshmi xoxo

View all our Fake Bake Recipes

Leave a comment (all fields required)

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Search